Showing posts with label David Sant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label David Sant. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 7, 2014

Made in America: The Labels that Made Us

"I don't want to be labeled 'gay,'I want to be labeled 'a human who loves humans.'"
"I'm tired of being labeled. I'm an American. I'm not an African-American; I'm an American."
                                                                      -Raven-Symoné


              I came across a poster with a plain white t-shirt at a LGBT youth center in my early 20's that had the tagline "labels are for cloths not people".  It would always catch me off kilter when I would walk in and see gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender affirming language plastered elsewhere in the facility.  I remember at the time thinking... "Well, yeah...that makes sense..." in my own closeted little world of fear and internalized homophobia.  I, much like Raven-Symoné, wished for an identity that was mine and couldn't be claimed by anyone else.  Because it was safer. As a white, middle class, able bodied, protestant male I could make that claim fairly seamlessly if I chose to. Over time I got tired of the false sense of security that having a white-washed identity provided.  
            Indeed, Raven states that too she is "tired of being labeled",  though she wasn't speaking generically in this interview. Clearly here she is tired of being labeled "Gay" and "African American".   Her word choice seems odd to me as she made no opinion about her gender and is perfectly happy to repeat that she is an American. Yet, these two identities; they are essential and inseparable parts of who she is, who she is created from, and who she is created to be.  These two identities carry significant history and a collective responsibility to remember the past and collectively act to balance the inequities our forefathers created. 
            Most importantly however, GAY WOMEN of COLOR NEVER  have a platform to speak about their experience and not only their experience but the experience of people who have similar stories but, who have to fight to be heard amongst the throngs and the masses.  She had a profound opportunity to tell the world that she is a proud Black Gay Woman who is in love and maybe, some kid in some youth center could have heard her story.  Instead, she chose to use her time to talk about how label-less she is. Meanwhile, gay kids are ending their lives, trans men and women are being killed, and black men and women are being gunned down by police and "do gooder" white folks".  
            Also, I think it is important to understand that to say you are an American, is not an innocuous statement.  American is, perhaps, the most loaded of all the identities because it is to say that I am willing to own that I acknowledge not only the indescribable beauty of our collective history, but the annuls of horrors as well.  
           We are who we are. We cannot change our genetic history nor can we change our heritage despite the sound bites we provide through social media or through the inner workings of our minds.  When we embrace our identity, especially those disenfranchised and oppressed, we turn our burdens into our greatest blessings.  It is our duty as social workers, to encourage all to be proud of who they are and where they come from and to truly honor what it means to be human.
           

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Standing Guard Over Saraswati: The Freedom of Dissent

"In every age it has been the tyrant, the oppressor, and the exploiter who has wrapped himself in the cloak of patriotism, or religion, or both to deceive and overawe the People."
                                                                       -Eugene V. Debs, 1918
"My mother said I broke her heart...but it was my integrity that was important. Is that so selfish? It sells for so little, but it's all we have left in this place.  It is the very last inch of us...but within that inch we are free"
                                                                       -Alan Moore, V for Vendetta

  Today Egypt was drowned in violence.  It's army turned on it's civilians with arms and slaughtered hundreds of Morsi supporters simply because they wanted to be heard.  Alternately, when the Muslim Brotherhood was in power, they willfully ignored violence inflicted on the Coptic minority because they are different and are seen as a threat to power.
  In every age, in every part of the world, there are underground movements that seek the opportunity to climb out of the trenches and stand with their voices heard, without fear of ruin.  Enterprise and government (large and small) throughout history have made attempts to curb, stifle and snuff out those voices.  With righteous rage, ideas turn into movements and with collective action comes power.  Humans really aren't so different when faced with a wall of dissent. Whether in 17th century France, early 20th century Russia, or in 21st century America, people in power have supported corrupt government policies that continue to alienate and intimidate minority opinion and minority rights.  Governments, however democratically elected, do not act alone but with the silent approval of the masses who keep their hands on the wheel, eyes forward.
  Not unlike governments, corporations have the capacity and will to stifle any opinion or threat to their bottom line.  During the height of European expansion, large businesses expanded to the New and parts of the Old World to obtain goods not previously available to the masses of the Continent.  Whether in the Americas, India, the South Pacific or Africa, these new industries toppled local governments and often installed puppet institutions to continue to feed the expanding empires. More recently in parts of the developing world; gas, coffee, water and the like drive conglomerates to continue to suppress dissent in countries who's annual GDP are fractions of their annual profits.  Not unlike the factory conditions during the early 20th century, farm and factory workers are forced to slave from sun up to sun down for less than $1 per day so that we in the developed world can spend less on the items we desire.  In Bangladesh for example, textile exports continue to surge despite over 1,000 deaths in a factory collapse in April.  Calls for reform have trumpeted from all corners of the globe and yet tangible change in the country to protect it's workers have stalled as some corporations like Walmart and Gap refuse to allow collective bargaining agreements with their workers thus disallowing real progress.
  In the US and in many democratic nations, we hold virtuous principles in our hearts and lack the integrity to follow through with them because they interfere with our ends.  Dissent in any form outside of violence must be tolerated and at best celebrated because it demonstrates a truly free society.
  As a Social Worker, wherever you are in the world, whatever you do to change your part of the world. We are the voice for the voiceless and we are the embodiment of dissent.  We are the call to justice and the rallying cry of freedom.  Where we see opinions and beliefs stifled, even if we disagree with them, we must stand with their right to say it.  That is how we maintain our integrity within our profession.  

Monday, January 21, 2013

Out of the Blue and into the Black: The Global Incarceration of the Mentally Ill.

"I proceed, gentlemen, briefly to call your attention to the present state of insane persons confined within this Commonwealth, in cages, closets, cellars, stalls, pens!  Chained, naked, beaten with rods, and lashed into obedience."
      -Dorothea Dix, Memorial to the  legislature of Massachusetts, 1843


               The red, sun baked earth crunches under the boots of a security guard outside a ward of the Enugu Prison, in the southeastern portion of Nigeria.  Unlike other sections of this prison, this portion of the prison has been set aside for people the government has listed as "civil lunatics".  According to the BBC, thanks to legislation from British era administration, the government can incarcerate individuals based on their perceived mental illness, often indefinitely.  In similar ways to asylums and hospitals in 1960's America, both family members and police can request an individual be sent to the ward without sufficient evidence of a crime or dangerous behavior.  More often than not, the request is granted.

              On January 7th, Idaho Governor, C.L (Butch) Otter gave his State of the State address to the Idaho legislature.  Otter, who is an outspoken critic of the Affordable Care Act, provided an extensive outline of his ideas to bring quality health care to the residents of the state.  One such recommendation, stemming from a request from the Department of Corrections was to build a $70 million, 579 bed, secure "mental health facility".  This is the Governor's second attempt to create such an institution for the incarcerated mentally ill.  The Department of Corrections and the contracted Corrections Corporation of America came under fire in 2010 with an ACLU exposé on prison conditions that foster extreme prisoner to prisoner violence. "Marlin Riggs, one of six named plaintiffs in the lawsuit, entered ICC in May 2008 and was targeted by a group of prisoners he believed were associated with a gang that prison officials knew had a history of threatening and extorting money from other prisoners. Despite his pleas, prison officials refused to move Riggs to a safer living area and he was violently assaulted and left lying in a pool of his own blood with a broken nose and a crushed cheekbone." 
                In 2003, the Hartford Courant published a story about the mentally ill in Connecticut's prisons.  They report that at Garner Correctional Institution in Newtown (the same town that a young man living with mental illness opened fire on an elementary school) "a schizophrenic man with a long history of severe psychiatric illness was intentionally deprived of his medication, became agitated and was fatally asphyxiated while being shackled by guards." The article goes on to state that "one inmate at this state's maximum-security facility was intentionally denied anti-psychotic medication that had been ordered by his psychiatrist and then tied to a steel bed frame for 22 hours. Another young schizophrenic man at the Hartford Correctional Center was asphyxiated by guards and then- while unconscious and dying- injected with powerful sedatives, shackled to a bed and left in a cell, naked and alone. He was discovered dead several hours later."
              From Canada to the United Kingdom, Japan to South Africa individuals living with mental illness are warehoused in prisons that are overcrowded, isolated from social supports, and a lack of evidenced based treatments.  According to the World Health Organization, an estimated 450 million people are living with mental illness at any given time.  In prisons however, individuals with mental illness are disproportionally represented compared to the general population in the countries where they live.  The WHO has identified that prison environments are in fact an impediment for the treatment of psychiatric disorders, even for those who committed serious crimes while ill.  Despite the availability, knowledge and resources of effective treatments, governments around the world continue to penalize the mentally ill whether they committed a crime or not.
              Most countries around the world carry puritanical ideologies regarding individuals who break the social contract of the culture that they find themselves. Even in countries that guarantee freedom from cruel and unusual punishment, conditions in prisons and jails lack basic structures to maintain the dignity and worth of the individuals housed there.  However, for individuals who are living with severe and persistent mental illness, they are often not only deprived of their civil rights, but their ability to connect to others as they are forced into isolation in solitary confinement despite evidence that this in fact worsens or creates mental illness.  The stigma of having mental illness and committing a crime are often compounded by racism, anti-gay, anti-transgender, and anti-poor sentiment.
             Social workers can utilize the strategies outlined by the World Health Organization to improve the lives of individuals living with mental illness as well as their families.  Regardless of the abundance of resources, each country has mental health systems in place that can be utilized and expanded to prevent the incidents that cause the incarceration of the mentally ill.  If in prison or jail, providing immediate, comprehensive, evidence based treatment in lieu of punishment would shorten the time an individual is locked up and save valuable tax dollars.  Providing adequate training for all staff on mental illness and treatment would reduce stigma and increase positive outcomes for prisoners.  Lastly, the WHO recommends that all legislation take a human rights perspective when directing legislative agendas for the mentally ill.
            The quote at the beginning of this post is taken from testimony from Dorothea Dix, a nurse and social reformer who sought to improve the lives of individuals living with mental illness from the squalor and penal environments that they lived.  More than 150 years since she spoke in the Massachusetts General Court, individuals around the world and here in America continue to live in the same conditions she sought to correct.  As social work professionals we can honor her memory to finish the fight she started so long ago.  Indeed, we must to stay true to our commitment to the dignity and worth of all peoples.


Thursday, January 17, 2013

The Conspiracy of a Black President

Across the lines
Who would dare to go
Under the bridge
Over the tracks
That separates whites from blacks
Chose sides
Or run for your life
                    -Tracy Chapman

           
            To be forthcoming, I am a white American male writing about racism.  I have never known the sting of hate nor the fear that accompanies citizens of African, Asian or Latin American descent.  I am going to do my best to be clear, concise and relevant.  This post is intended to be the beginning (or at least a part of) a discussion about recent events in American history.  Indeed, there is a large amount of evidence that I have left out that should be a part of this post both domestically and abroad.  As long as it is respectful, please feel free to leave any comments, thoughts or experiences.
           As most of my readers are aware the last half of 2012 experienced several high profile acts of domestic terrorism ranging from a gunman opening fire on an Aurora, Colorado movie theatre to an attack at a Sikh temple in Wisconsin and most recently, the slaughter of 20 first graders at a Connecticut elementary school.  These events, amongst others have reignited and in many circles inflamed gun owners and gun advocates to seek change.  As always in American politics, the solution is where politicians and advocates differ.  Each side of the political spectrum has fringe elements who hold the fundamentalist ideals of their affiliation to heart.  Attached to these fringe characters are conspiracy theorists who believe in a panacea of government cover ups that include aliens landing at Roswell, the moon landing, the assassination of JFK, and the 9/11 attacks.  However, since the mass slaughter of children in Newtown, a new conspiracy has developed out of the belief that the federal government had a role in the deaths of these children...so that they can take guns away from Americans.  
              Since the first term of the President, the number of hate groups identified by the Southern Poverty Law Center increased to over 1000 in 2011 stemming from a reaction to anti-immigrant sentiment and demographic shifting.  The primary indicator of this reaction however, came from the election of the first African descent president in American history.  To be clear, both sides of the political spectrum have racist attitudes.  On the right, often this manifests in a more direct and personally attacking way. On the left, this often translates to structural discrimination and inaccurate beliefs about a  group of people (though both sides are alternately guilty).  However, since the election, facets of the right has specifically felt somehow disenfranchised by the election and believe that this indeed a sign that things in America has gone from bad to terrible.  Out of this movement many conspiracies have developed that have made national headlines.  Early after the election many people believed (and continue to believe) that the President's birth certificate was a forgery, that he is a practicing Muslim, that his government withheld information regarding the attack at the consulate in Benghazi, Libya, and now that he is trying to disarm American citizens.
           No other President has endured these claims which seek to de-legitimize not only his qualifications for office, but his allegiance to the country he leads.  To be blunt, if he was a white American, they would be attacking his politics...not his identity and character.  As with the conspiracies that surround the 9/11 terrorist attacks, insinuating that our democracy is responsible for the deaths of innocent 6 year olds is the lowest form of racist ideology to come out of the Tea Party/Patriot/Doomsday Prepper movement.
          Regardless if we identify as a Democrat, Republican, Green, or Libertarian, we must confront the prejudicial thoughts that run through our minds when we see someone who looks different than ourselves.   Only then can we begin to debunk the racist clutter in our heads and look at the picture as it really is.  To be clear. Neither Muslims nor Hindus nor Sikhs nor "Zionists" nor Gays nor Mexicans nor people of African descent are at fault for acts of terror or crimes against humanity. Terrorists and war criminals are at fault for acts of terror or crimes against humanity.   As always, Social Workers must be at the forefront of the battle against the ever-present racist actions and ideologies that continue to cradle this great nation and around the world.
          
          

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

United States of Fear

"And of course, the approach [to build] a multicultural [society] and to live side-by-side and to enjoy each other... has failed, utterly failed."
 -Angela Merkel, German Chancellor

"Rape and incest was used as a reason to oppose this. I would hope that when a woman goes into a physician, with a rape issue, that that physician will indeed ask her about perhaps her marriage, was this pregnancy caused by normal relations in a marriage, or was it truly caused by a rape." 
            -Chuck Winder, Idaho State Senate  Assistant Majority Leader

"That's what we're talking about whenever you're talking about gay rights. You're talking about giving somebody a gun to put at the head of anybody who disagrees with them, whether it's the Boy Scouts, whether it's a local dry-cleaning establishment or a giant corporation like Shell Oil." 
            -Robert Knight, Family Research Council

"[Gypsies] are nomads and nobody can do anything about them...they will bring their horses into the flats and there any attempt to civilize them ends...we should build special camps and keep them outside our cities."
           -Traian Bäsescu, Romanian President (Then Mayor of Bucharest)

   In 2008 when President Barack Obama was inaugurated, the world watched in hope that it would usher in a shining new era from what many saw as the draconian Bush years.  This reverberated so strongly that in 2009, President Obama was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize "for his extraordinary efforts to strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between peoples."  
      Much of the world saw him almost as a messiah figure whom to pin their belief that things were in fact, going to get better.  However like most idols, he could not live up to the herculean mission the world had placed on him.  In fact, his rise to the presidency coincided with the largest spike in the number of hate groups in memory and issues of racism, thought by much of white America to be a relic of the past, exploded to the surface.  This blog post is not intended to be a discussion about race politics in the US (hopefully that will be a discussion later on), but a commentary on the continental shifts in the US and around the globe that have occurred (and continue) since January of 2009.  
  Following on the heels of the collapse of Lehman Brothers and the housing crisis that we are all familiar with (some more intimately than others) began the worst global economic disaster since the market went belly up in 1929. Unlike previous regional problems like the collapse of several Latin American economys in the 1980's and the Asian financial crisis in the late 1990's; this was truly an economic pandemic.  Parts of the developing world recovered much quicker than the rest. The economic engine driving China, Brazil, and India barely slowed as they plowed through the recession.  In the developed world, especially the US and Europe, the recession may "officially" be over,but the  economic situation has continued to deteriorate.  Austerity measures in Greece have disenfranchised many jobless in the country and has yet to turn the Greek economy out of the red. In fact, talks about the Greek departure from the Eurozone is becoming more common in the European political arena.  Even Spain, the Eurozone's 4th biggest economy finally requested up to €100 billion to bail out of its banking sector.  The latest job figures in the United States show that only 69,000 jobs were created in May 2012 while unemployment rose to 8.2% nationally. 
  As the economic crisis deepens in many parts of the world, other social problems such as poverty, hunger, homelessness, debt, amongst others have been exacerbated.  Social discontent, while a permanent fixture on one level or another throughout history, has exploded throughout the world fueled by social media and easy access to information, with the "Arab Spring" as the most notable.   
  Underpinning this discontent is a layer of fear and anxiety about what the future may bring.  Interest in the "End Times" has reappeared in its current form through the ancient Mayan calendar and prophesies and television shows such as Ancient Aliens, the Universe, Ancient Discoveries, etc. have provided viewers with information about this event.  In fact, social media continues to have an impact through film (2012, Prometheus), television (Doomsday Preppers), books and articles (Post-American World, Third World America), and news outlets. 
  Unfortunately, when people become afraid, they'll turn to anyone who promises a solution.  Too often, the solutions include blaming "the other" for the losses that have been felt.  In France, members of the  Roma community were "repatriated" to Romania due to what officials called a "decent and humane" decision to move the individuals out of poor living conditions.  However, many in France accused then President Nicolas Sarkozy of pandering to the far right in his country as many believe that the nomadic Roma brought crime to the country with them when their countries of origin joined the Schengen Zone.  Also in France, as well as much of Europe, Islamophobia and antisemitism have launched new agenda's within the far right to curb immigration and as retribution against the actions of the State of Israel.  Violence against these groups are not uncommon. 
  In late May 2012, the FBI's hate biased crimes report showed that hate crimes have risen in the last year.  This has been true especially in the LGBT community where recent reports show that while probably under reported, this community is victimized 6 times the overall rate for the year of all groups.  Ministers in churches all over the country have advocated for the slaughter of gays as well and often ascribe the social ills of the country to the growing acceptance of the gay community.
  Within the last legislative session, women's reproductive rights have been increasingly restricted in many states across the US and throughout the world.  Initiatives to ban funding for organizations such as Planned Parenthood that provide abortion services have been attempted both on the federal and on state levels.  While the bulk of services that this organization provides are information, referral, family planning, rape crisis intervention, breast cancer screenings,etc., many on the right have used this state of fear to it's advantage to attack these services based on the small percentage of abortions provided each year. 
  As the ambitions of the far right continue to capitalize on the growing anxiety of the masses, social workers must continue to think critically about social problems and address them in a manner that is fact based and remain opposed to scapegoating of any population.  Even when we philosophically disagree with an individual or group we must remember that no one person nor a portion of a group can speak for the whole. 
  It will be interesting to see the dialogue as the US elections heat up toward November.  The first LDS front runner candidate against the first African American incumbent.  Two groups that have been historically marginalized in the US and who even have a divisive history amongst themselves.  As social workers we should remain on the forefront of issues facing the populations that we serve and respond promptly to any and all hate motivated speech targeted toward either candidate due to their minority status. 
 
Have you seen or read about anything related to this article? 
Please post your thoughts in the comment section. 
While all opinions are welcome. In order to create a safe space for dialogue, hate speech is not and will be removed.
   

Saturday, December 3, 2011

Going Bust: The Vanishing Middle Class

Courtesy of the Library of Congress
"It's no longer an exaggeration to say that middle-class Americans are an endangered species."
         -Arianna Huffington



"Slums may well be breeding grounds of crime, but middle-class suburbs are incubators of apathy and delirium"
         -Cyril Connolly


"As mass production has to be accompanied by mass consumption, mass consumption, in turn, implies a distribution of wealth - not of existing wealth, but of wealth as it is currently produced - to provide men with buying power equal to the amount of goods and services offered by the nation's economic machinery.  Instead of achieving that kind of distribution, a giant suction pump had by 1929-1930 drawn into a few hands an increasing portion of currently produced wealth.  This served them as capital accumulations.  But by taking purchasing power out of the hands of mass consumers, the savers denied to themselves the kind of effective demand for their products that would justify a reinvestment of their capital accumulations in new plants.  In consequence, as in a poker game where the chips were concentrated in fewer and fewer hands, the other fellows could stay in the game only by borrowing.  When their credit ran out, the game stopped."
  The above borrowed from Marriner Eccles' memoir, "Beckoning Frontiers" summarizes prophetically the economic climate of the United States since the late 1970's.  As the child of poor Mormon Scottish immigrants, Eccles embodied the idyllic American success story by creating a large financial empire.  At the time of the Great Depression, he was one of the few business tycoons to continue to stay above water. His realizations about the origins of the worst financial disaster in world history contributed greatly to the eventual recovery, stabilization and unparalleled economic growth that lasted from 1947 to 1975.  The direct result of what became known as the New Deal, which comprised a multitude of programs including the Social Security Administration, Public Works Administration, the Work Projects Administration and employment boom as a result of WWII, was arguably the greatest invention of the 20th century; the middle class.  While not all Americans benefited equally during this time period (racial minorities, women), the rise of the middle class with the safety nets allowed people to live what we now know as the American Dream.  
  Beginning in 1975, new movements of both social and fiscal conservatism, which glorified protestant individualism and laissez faire economics began to erode the safety nets created by both the New Deal and the War on Poverty.  Taxes on the wealthiest Americans also began to shrink under the guise of trickle down economics, or the belief that wealth given to the top will be distributed down the social ladder.  In 1928, as the Great Depression loomed on the horizon, the top 1% earned almost 25% of the total income.  After the New Deal, wealth became more evenly distributed and allowed greater purchasing power for the middle class.  After 1975, deregulation and lower taxation of the wealthiest Americans concentrated more wealth at the top of the economic ladder.  The middle class, accustomed to a quality standard of living began to, for the first time, use credit in large amounts to maintain their lifestyles.  By December 2007 the top 1% was again earning roughly 25% of the total income in the country.  
  Today, the American Dream remains in the hearts of most Americans.  The belief that each generation will have a better life than the previous through hard work and dedication.  Indeed, there seems to be a belief amongst the middle and lower classes that if we were to increase taxes on the rich, then it would hurt them later down the road when they too become rich.  Reality however is much dimmer.  The roads believed to be paved with gold are now filled with potholes as more and more middle class Americans lose their sense of well being and are now simply trying to survive.  According to the Brookings Institute, between 2000 and 2008 the percentage of suburbians living in poverty grew by 25% making suburban America, once the symbol of prosperity, the largest and fastest growing segment of the poor.  Opportunities of upward mobility in America are shrinking and according to CNN Money Canada, Germany, France and all of Scandinavia have higher rates of social mobility.
  This post certainly is not comprehensive nor does it mean that only a few factors lead the middle class to where it is today.  The implications of the vanishing middle class however are clear.  This group has historically been the maintaining force of American democracy as we know it through taxes and voting power and according to teacher, historian, and author Gail Chumbley, is the binding that holds the world together.  Middle class pioneers  who have the luxury of having a voice were and continue to be the defining force of the greatest progressive social movements of the 20th and 21st centuries and acts as a shield against plutocracy and cronyism.  As the middle class erodes and more people slip into survival mode, social, political and economic power will consolidate into the hands of the few.  This is evidenced by more tax loopholes for the rich, the disintegration of collective bargaining agreements and blame placed on the middle and working classes for their current situation.  In the late 19th century individuals who profited at the expense of their workers were known as robber barons (though they referred to themselves as captains of industry).  Today, they are known job creators and are symbols of  American economic mobility.  Without the middle class, modern capitalism will end and the United States will begin to resemble the developing world where the rich live behind gated walls and the rest barely
survive.  
  The profession of social work depends on the middle class for its survival as well.  With limited entitlement programs, a reduction of donations to non-profits and a stagnation of wages, social workers will be unable to fulfill its mission to reduce poverty, enfranchise marginalized populations, and promote the welfare of all.  As a united profession both in the US and abroad, we must act through legislative outreach and grassroots community organizing to change the economic and social destruction of the middle class.  Indeed, self-preservation demands it.

Further Reading on the Decline of the Middle Class

Aftershock: The Next Economy and America's Future by Robert B. Reich

Third World America: How Our Politicians are Abandoning the Middle Class and Betraying the American Dream by Arianna Huffington

Falling From Grace: The Experience of Downward Mobility in the American Middle Class by Katherine Newman

Wealth and Democracy: A Political History of the American Rich by Kevin Phillips

The American Dream vs. The Gospel of Wealth by Norton Garfinkle

Monday, September 19, 2011

Banned Books and Human Rights

"Books and ideas are the most effective weapons against intolerance and ignorance."
                                     -Lyndon Johnson

"If there is a bedrock principle underlying the First Amendment, it is that the government may not prohibit the expression of an idea simply because society finds the idea itself offensive or disagreeable."
                           -Supreme Court Justice William J. Brennan, Jr.

  In 2006, after jail time, repeated death threats and harassment, Anna Politkovskaya was shot and killed in her home in Russia.  During her life she bravely published on human rights abuses in Chechnya, on state corruption, military violence, and police brutality in spite of serious threats of harm.  Even though her murder received wide spread international attention, her alleged killer wasn't arrested until May 31, 2011 (Amnesty International).
  Every year during Banned Books Week (September 24th-October 1st), Amnesty International showcases individuals from all over the world who have been harassed, tortured, imprisoned or killed because of the things that they have written, often due to the writer's exposure of human rights abuses or for writing a critical analysis of a country.
  The correlation between human rights and freedom of speech/press has been explored in many western countries since the mid-18th century (arguably even earlier).  In his play, "Almansor", published in 1821, German poet and playwright Heinrich Heine wrote, "Dort, wo man Bücher verbrennt, verbrennt man am Ende auch Menchen." (Where they burn books, they will also ultimately burn people).  This was chillingly prophetic in that roughly one hundred years later Fascist and Communist governments censored books, magazines, and newspapers critical of government activities or those thought to be counterrevolutionary.  On May 10th, 1933 the most famous of these events took place in Berlin and other major university towns in Germany.  German students who had adopted fascist, antisemitic ideology sponsored events to purge the country of "un-German spirit".  Their activities ended with the burning of over 25,000 books.  The largest event took place in the Opernplatz in Berlin where 40,000 people came to hear a man by the name of Joseph Goebbels speak.  During his speech to the crowd he stated, "No to decadence and moral corruption...Yes to decency and morality in family and state.  I consign to the flames the writings of Heinrich Mann, Ernst Gläser, and Erich Kästner."  These events were an early expression of hatred for the Jewish people (and Gay men, Roma, communists, Jehovah's Witnesses, Poles amongst others) that ended with the mass murder of over 6 million people.
  While most industrialized countries and indeed many developing countries mandate freedom of speech and press constitutionally or through common law, various works deemed "immoral" or "dangerous" are banned on national, state/provincial or local levels in schools, public libraries and online.  Countries that have been criticised for censorship include China, Iran, Cuba and North Korea.
  The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which has served as the foundation of international law includes freedom of speech and press as rights afforded to people simply because they are human. Article 19 states, "Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive, and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers."
  The United States however has not been immune from threats of censorship.  The American Library Association (ALA) created Banned Books Week to highlight the need for awareness of attempts to censor books and other publication materials.  The organization sites three major reasons for these attempts.
   -Sexually explicit material
   -Offensive Language
   -Unsuited to any age group
  While the American Library Association understands why individuals would want certain books banned, their position is that, "Librarians and governing bodies should maintain that parents- and only parents- have the right and the responsibility to restrict the access of their children- and only their children- to library resources."
  Examples of the most banned books in the US during the 2000-2009 decade includes: the "Harry Potter" series by JK Rowling, "His Dark Materials" series by Phillip Pullman, "Of Mice and Men" by John Steinbeck, and "I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings" by Maya Angelou.


Monday, August 29, 2011

Eugenics, Race, And A Woman's Right To Chose

"...the Negro lacks in his germ plasm excellence of some qualities which the white race possess, and which are essential for success in competition with the civilizations of the white races at the present day."
                                            - California, 1926

  Eugenics (termed by Francis Galton), or the means to "improve" the human race through infanticide, forced sterilization or genetic manipulation of those individuals deemed inferior (mental illness, low IQ, the poor, criminals, etc.) is rooted in the ancient philosophic works of Plato and Aristotle and has continued up to the present day.  The modern eugenics movement began in the late 19th century in the United States with the belief that criminality, imbecility and mental illness were hereditary and therefore should be controlled through forced sterilization or forced removal of "feeble-minded" children.   Some of the biggest proponents of the era weren't fringe characters or Nazi idealists but were arguably some of the most influential people of their time.  These included President Theodore Roosevelt, Planned Parenthood founder Margaret Sanger, Winston Churchill, and Economist John Maynard Keynes.  While the early years of the eugenics movement focused on poor white Americans, by the 1930's most of the forced sterilizations were on poor women of color.  Rooted in the belief that African Americans, Mexican Americans and Native Americans were genetically inferior to European Americans, social scientists of the day saw this reflected in data showing lower performance in education and in criminality.
  The Supreme Court showed the practice to be constitutionally viable in 1927 (Buck v. Bell) in regard to  the prevention of children born to people with disabilities.  The movement saw its greatest momentum between 1907 and 1968 when between 65,000 and 100,000 people were sterilized.  Clinics were placed in poor neighborhoods and eugenics propaganda was spread throughout America through county fairs where "fit family" contests were frequent.  This was not without notice to the rest of the world.  Nazi Germany used the eugenic framework from the US and other countries to justify the forced sterilizations of people with mental illness and developmental disabilities and the mass slaughter of Jews, Poles, Roma, Gays and others to root out less desirable races from their midst.
  The American social work profession, always being in transition, was unfortunately a major player in eugenics practices as they often were the gatekeepers of who received the procedure and who did not.  This also remained true in other countries where eugenic practices were the accepted "humanitarian" philosophy.
  In the wake of the Civil Rights Movement and the Feminist Movement of the 1960's, eugenic practices began to become highly unpopular as biologic science and social science began to show that race was not biologically determined but socially constructed.  Deficiencies in the classroom and overrepresentation in the prison system were shown to be the result of racist institutions and not on the genetic makeup of the individual.  Around this time social work also began to discredit eugenic philosophy as deeply flawed and shifted to a self-determination framework.  This fell in line with the belief that women have the right to informed reproductive health decisions and that the individual, not the state, has the right to choose regardless of race, gender or socio-economic status.
  Today eugenic practices seem to be nothing but a ghostly whisper from the past.  Indeed it has been relegated as junk science by most if not all mainstream professional organizations.  However, in much of the world, especially the Global South, women continue to lack access to reproductive freedom and up to date reproductive health information.  As a result of gender discrimination and poverty, women in the developing world are still at high risk of unwanted pregnancies, low education and literacy rates, HIV/AIDS, fistula, and maternal mortality.  In many parts of Asia, a war on girls is being waged in gender sex selection with a cultural preference to have boys.  This has lead to a major gender gap with a disproportionate number of boys over girls.  In China, with the one child policy, families without means are committing infanticide, aborting, or putting up for adoption girls in favor of their only child being a boy.
  Another modern concern arose with the advent of the Human Genome Project, an international collaboration to sequence the entire human genome.  This is believed to eventually lead to cures of genetic disorders, cancer, diabetes, mental illness, etc. and has been hailed as one of the greatest feats of modern science.   Indeed, one's perceived genetic make-up has lead to terrible atrocities in the past and with a future of designer babies, human-animal chimeras, and other eventualities, precautions must be made to prevent eugenic type philosophies from taking root again.
  One such precaution is for social workers to have a basic understanding of genetics if not have fluency in the field.  The National Association of Social Workers has developed practice standards for integrating genetic science into ones framework.  The inclusion of genetics into the education of social workers allows them to have the necessary tools to advocate with clients on all levels and to provide relevant information so clients may make informed decisions about their lives.

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Welfare vs. Development: A Social Worker's Call to Fighting Global Poverty

Every morning our newspapers could report, "More than 20,000 people perished yesterday of extreme poverty."
                    -Jeffery D. Sachs
                     The End of Poverty

  In July 2011, news outlets from across the globe reported that parts of Somalia is in the midst of crushing famine while the rest of the country and parts of Ethiopia, Kenya, and Djibouti are in crisis.  Drought, conflict, inability to receive aid, death of livestock and other factors have forced millions of Somali's into extreme hunger and food insecurity and a quarter of the population has been displaced.  The BBC reports that 6 out of 10,000 children die from starvation and disease in Somalia every day.
  The situation in East Africa sadly is but a microcosm of what societies in the margins around the world are experiencing.  According to the UNDP (United Nations Development Programme) 1.4 billion people  were living under the international poverty line of $1.25 per day as of 2005 and this number increases to roughly 2.5 billion who live on less than $2 per day.  While the vast majority of those living in extreme poverty live in the developing world (Global South), the developed world (Global North) is not immune from its effects.  In fact, as of 2006, roughly 37 million people living United States lives under the poverty line.  In America, poverty is not shared equally as 25% of African decent and 22% of Latinos live below this line compared to just under 9% of European decent.  Indeed, the poorest community in the US is the Pine Ridge Reservation where 97% live under the poverty line, unemployment hovers around 80% and males have a life expectancy of roughly 57 years.  In the west, only Haiti has lower statistics (The Observer, 2006).
  Those working in development define poverty in different ways due to the complexity of the issue.  Many however divide poverty into two terms; absolute poverty and relative poverty.  Absolute Poverty can be understood as the inability of people to sustain their basic needs while Relative Poverty is based on the income distribution within a given society. Indeed, those living under $11 dollars a day in the developed world is much higher than those living on less than $1 in the developing world, but in the context of the society they are also desperately poor.
  Differences between the Global North and the Global South lie not only in their respective poverty reduction strategies but in the terminology used.  In the developed world we use the term welfare or welfare state to describe the various tools used to combat poverty.  Different countries in the Global North utilize various models from the Scandinavian society based to the US needs based interventions.  Indeed in the United States, the term welfare has become a dirty word describing a lazy woman of color who doesn't want to stop having children.  This inaccurate and unfortunate stereotype further pushes America's poor into the margins of society.  Indeed welfare is intended as safety net which is meant to keep people from falling into extreme poverty. In the US, various programs such as TANF, Medicare and Medicaid act in various ways to assist those with the most need. Unfortunately this approach has also left many falling through the cracks and could be argued have only exacerbated the problems experienced by America's poor.
  In contrast, those interventions used in the developing world are known as development strategies.  Development strategies directly utilizes capacity building techniques as well as aid donations as means of poverty reduction.  Capacity building strategies include: microcredit/microfinance programs, promotion of primary education (especially for women and girls), building of sustainable infrastructure, incorporation of human rights, fighting government corruption, amongst others.  Development at its essence is the belief that people do not simply need a government handout, but have the ability to have an equitable standard of living with the correct capacity building resources in place.
  Social workers have been working to end poverty even before the global profession existed.  It is the base from which all other practice areas are enmeshed.  In our pursuit of social justice in accordance with our human rights framework, we must continue to work to reduce poverty and the ills that accompany it. To reduce poverty in the western world, social workers should utilize and promote the development strategies of the Global South and work to build capacity and promote equity amongst America's and the rest of the developed world's poor.  In fact, we must in order to fufill our mission as a profession.

Sunday, July 3, 2011

Religious Diversity-A Beginners Guide for Social Workers

  As long as there has been humans there has been wonder about the world in which they live.  Early humans saw the divine in all things from the air they breathed, the sun that shone down on them, the life they created, and the earth that they walked on.   From the traces of our ancestors we can see that the interconnectedness of the divine with other aspects of life was fundamental to their worldview and to their continued existence as a people. They lived to appease these beings through sacrifice, adoration, emulation, and devotion in all areas of life.   This remains true to today.
  Current global demographic data charts show that the world is a deeply religious planet with diverse belief systems that impact and react to each other in sometimes benign, sometimes explosive ways.  Often these interactions are viewed as Geo-political or cultural without regard to the religious undertones that exist just below the surface.   
  Social work education has begun to recognize the importance of understanding that human beings are spiritual creatures and that spirituality must be included into the person in the environment approach.  However, a distinction must be made between spirituality and religiosity in the social work conversation in order for social workers to effectively work with the diversity of peoples they encounter.  
Simply put, spirituality is the internal connection that an individual has with a power greater than themselves.   Indeed, religion is the external expression of belief through rituals, prayer, mediation, sacred readings and sacrifice.  Therefore, people can be spiritual and not religious and vise-versa.
  Understanding this distinction is essential for social workers to effectively work with and advocate for their clients.  Religion (or the lack of) is the base of which everything from interpersonal relationships to international policy is founded.  In an age with growing religious intolerance, especially Islamophobia, Anti-Semitism, persecution of Christians, Mormons, Baha'i and other groups, people in all corners of the globe live in fear for their very lives for the truths they believe they hold.  Truly, in the western world where values of freedom, fraternity, and democracy are enshrined, religious groups are persecuted even up to state sanctioned harassment.  
  Understanding religion in the social world is vital to understanding persecution of other groups deemed unclean or immoral by conservative religious groups such as gays, feminists, competing religious communities, pro-choice groups, racial minorities, indigenous peoples and others deemed apostates by religious philosophy.  In places such as the United States, politicians must have a perceived holy sanction to run for and win an office, even in progressive regions of the country.  
  Social workers can utilize religious beliefs to free their clients from persecution as well.  This has been done in many parts of the world to end enslavement, segregation, apartheid, homophobia, misogyny, and other social ills.  Indeed, it has even been used to free countries from colonizing or authoritarian regimes.  
  In our profession we must be culturally competent and understand the diversity that surrounds us in order for us to be effective advocates for change.  Social work education must incorporate a discussion from intangible and safe ideas about spirituality to real world expression of beliefs and the consequences of believing differently from ones neighbor. Indeed it must in order to remain true to its principles, ethical codes and its commitment to human rights.

Monday, May 23, 2011

Paradigm-From A Needs Based Perspective To A Rights Based Perspective

  With roots mired in the early 19th century imprint of the Monroe Doctrine, manifest destiny, and staunch protestant individualism, the social work profession's social justice framework began through working with individuals cast aside and living in the margins of society.  Both the National Association of Social Workers and the Council on Social Work Education require social workers to have an understanding and a committment to social justice in our work.  What remains unclear however is a solid working definition of social justice.  The profession's ethical codes suggest an egalitarian model in which "...the needs of all must be considered (Reichert, 2001)."  Distribution of various resources should be allocated so that the basic needs of all individuals are met equitably.  Indeed, the term is enmeshed within the profession and images of equality and fraternity surface with its mention.  However,  with its needs based paradigm and its lack of clear definitions the term is less useful to the populations that the profession seeks to enfranchise.
  American social work is unique in the world in that its focus is on social justice instead of the universal ideas of human rights.  To date, the two major social work bodies in the US lack a clear understanding of the role of human rights within the social work paradigm while the rest of the world uses human rights as the pillar for all work with vulnerable and oppressed populations.
  Human rights, meaning those rights that are endowed to individuals, groups and societies because they are essential to our humanity, have been encoded in international law through the United Nations and other intergovernmental organizations.  The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, though non-binding, offers more clear definitions that the profession in the US can use to further improve the lives of all peoples.  By moving from a social justice framework to a human rights framework, social workers can advocate for the civil, social, political, economic and cultural rights of their constituents from a more substantive framework that not only illicits powerful images, but makes a profound and tangible impact on the world.  Using a human rights framework, social workers would be able to argue that not only do Americans need and deserve universal health care, but they have a fundimental right to universal health care as outlined in international law.
  Human rights insists that the profession call for an end to the busting of collective barganing groups, the creation of equitable policies in TANF, an end to the attacks on women's reproductive rights, and acts of sexism, racism, homophobia, xenophobia, and other forms of hate to be viewed not just as violations of law but violations of those rights guaranteed to us by birth as human beings.
  The United States has only ratified those internatinonal treaties which focus on polictical and civil rights while ignoring economic, social and cultural rights.  The social work profession has been a great lobbying force on various issues that face disenfranchised groups. In order for the profession to advocate for the passage of these other human rights conventions, we must understand and have a committment to human rights in the same way we have done with social justice.
  In truth, it is unlikely that social justice will disappear from the social work conversation at any point in the forseeable future.  With the inclusion of human rights however, social workers will be able to more effectively and positively stand with targeted groups both here and throughout the world.

For further information on incorporating human rights into the social work profession click here

Monday, May 16, 2011

American Myopia- A Short Story of Genocide

"I am tired of fighting.  Our chiefs are killed.  The old men are all dead.  It is cold and we have no blankets.  The little children are freezing to death.  My people,. some of them, have run away to the hills and have no blankets, no food.  No one knows where they are--perhaps freezing to death.  Maybe I shall find them among the dead.  From where the sun now stands, I will fight no more forever."
- Chief Joseph, Nez Perce, 1877

    It is estimated that when Christopher Columbus "discovered" America in 1492, as many as 100 million people were living on the North and South American continents.  Beginning with the islands of the Caribbean, Spanish conquistadors moved as locusts through the Americas forcing the native populations into slavery along the way.  This utterly elimanated the populations on modern day Puerto Rico, Jamaica, Hispanola and other islands in the region.  In modern day Mexico, where it is estimated that 12 million lived, the conquistadors ravaged the countryside looking for gold.  In their wake disease, forced conversion to Christianity, and mass extermination decimated the native Mexican peoples.  In what is now Canada, in a period of 300 years, the population dwindled from roughly 2 million people to around 500,000 by the turn of the 20th century.  in 1830, a US policy known as the Indian Removal Act fed by the power of the Monroe Doctrine created conditions which forced native people from their ancestral lands, the most well known being the forced removal of the Cherokee and Choctaw tribes.   This became known as the Trail of Tears due to the deaths of thousands from starvation, exhaustion and disease.  Once American Indians were forced onto reservations, their children were taken and placed in Christian schools where they were forced to learn English, convert to Christianity and were not allowed to display any cultural norms from home.
  From 1981-1983 the Guatemalan military slaughtered thousands of Maya peoples under the backdrop of a civil war because they were suspected of being part of a communist group wanting to overthrow the current government.  Children were thrown against walls like ragdolls and adults were hunted down and slaughtered.  Livestock and crops were destroyed, drinking water polluted.  As common in eliminationist movements, Mayan women were systematically raped.  Throughout the genocide, the United States supported the Guatemalan government to contain the percieved growth of communism.  Most of the perpetrators have recieved amnesty including the military leader of the time who is now a member of the Guatemalan congress.
 Today remains a legacy of exclusion, gross human rights violations, health disparities,  cultural destruction and political invisibility that continues to disenfranchise the indigenous populations of the Americas.  Short sighted policies that leave tribes absent in the American conversation continue to reek havoc on the well being and futures of all native peoples.
  As shown in our Code of Ethics, we as a profession must work with indigenous populations in culturally appropriate ways that seek to advance the well being of their societies.  We must be aware of the collective histories that profoundly impacts the todays and tomorrows of native peoples.  For too long the struggle of the peoples of North and South America has been fought unacknowledged by the larger society.  Social workers should be part of this continued struggle and assist in bringing it to light.

Further Reading on the topic includes, Blood and Soil: A World History of Genocide and Extermination from Sparta to Darfur by Ben Kiernan and The Earth Shall Weep: A History of Native America by James Wilson.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Ordinary Justice-A Fight for Global Equality

     "This is a matter of ordinary justice. We struggled against apartheid in South Africa, supported by people the world over, because black people were being blamed and made to suffer for something we could do nothing about — our very skins. It is the same with sexual orientation. It is a given. I could not have fought against the discrimination of apartheid and not also fight against the discrimination that homosexuals endure, even in our churches and faith groups (Tutu, D. 2004)." 
                                                                           -Archbishop Desmond Tutu
     
     The world faces complex and compounding challenges as it enters the second decade of the 21st century: famine, war, poverty, economic instability, gender inequality, and religious intolerance, amongst others. Often, the issues surrounding international gay and lesbian human rights violations takes the backseat. Injustice seeps from every corner of the globe towards gay men and women. Truly, even the United Nations is struggling to pass a non-binding declaration on LGBT equal rights (Macfarquhar, N., 2008). Stigma and discrimination vary from country to country and often people feel it is unsafe to live openly and even fear for their very lives, every moment of every day. This silence can be deadly however, as gay and lesbian individuals, on many occasions battle alone. In many countries gay men and women face state sponsored oppression, either directly through violence or indirectly by refusing to intervene when human rights are being violated. In Iraq, armed militias have been slaughtering suspected gay citizens. Beginning in 2009 in the capital of Baghdad, the violence has spread to many parts of the country (Human Rights Watch, 2009). In a statement made to Human Rights Watch, an Iraqi man describes the abduction of his boyfriend of close to a decade.
       “It was late one night, and they came to take my partner at his parents' home. Four armed men barged into the house, masked and wearing black. They asked for him by name; they insulted him and took him in front of his parents. ... He was found in the neighborhood the day after. They had thrown his corpse in the garbage. His genitals were cut off and a piece of his throat was ripped out (Human Rights Watch, 2009)." 
       According to BBC News, as of July 2009, 31 women in South Africa had been reported to the police to have been murdered and raped because of their sexual orientation. This form of hate crime, known as conversion or ‘corrective’ rape is intended and believed to create a heterosexual woman out of the crime. Many of the women are black and live in poverty in townships surrounding larger communities, such as Johannesburg.
     “I was raped because I was a butch child. I was 13 years old the first time it happened. My mother walked into the room soon afterwards and said to me ‘this is what happens to girls like you (Mufweba, Y.)” - South Africa
     Due to the marginalization of women, rape is a common occurrence in South Africa with 1 in 4 men admitting that they had engaged in forced sexual intercourse (Jecks, N.). Gay women, however, are targeted not only because of their gender but also because of their gender expression and their sexual identity. 
       “There are many issues that lesbians have to deal with besides being marginalized as women. There is intolerance at all levels- the media, health officials, education, the police, family (Mufweba, Y.).” 
       The growing apathy towards rape and especially rape of lesbians is evident in that within the 31 lesbians to come forward about their rape, only two cases were ever heard in court, and only one of those resulted in a conviction (Jecks, N.). 
         On July 19th, 2005 two young Iranian teenage boys, one age 18 and one slightly younger, were convicted and executed by hanging in a town in northern Iran for allegedly raping a 13-year-old boy, although this has been seen by many to be used as a cover for consensual sexual activity that these boys participated in. The Islamic Republic of Iran prescribes the death penalty for men who engage in homosexual or perceived homosexual behavior. Gay people in Iran are faced with state sponsored harassment, prison time, torture, and execution if their identity or perceived identity is made available to police or government leaders. Often, the government uses false allegations to heighten the charges against the individuals (Amnesty International, 2005). 
         Iran is not alone in is policies toward its LGBT citizens. According to the International Lesbian and Gay Association (2010), 5 other nations prescribe the death penalty for alleged homosexual acts between consenting adults. These countries include; Mauritania, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Yemen, and 12 northern provinces in Nigeria which ascribe to Islamic Sharia Law and to a lesser extent some southern parts of Somalia. This list does not include the countries where same sex acts are illegal though the death penalty is not prescribed. This includes 38 countries in Africa, 23 countries in Asia, 11 in Latin American and the Caribbean, and 9 in Oceana. Punishments range from a fine to life imprisonment. Gay men and women in these countries must hide their identity and participate in behavior that defies their true feelings, such as heterosexual marriage, forced sexual relations with their spouse, gender-normative friends, participation in typical sex roles, and extreme religiosity. 
      Even in places such as South Africa, Brazil, the United States and Armenia where same sex relations have been decriminalized, gays and lesbians still face persecution as there are no laws to protect them or current laws are not enforced. Police, authorities, popular sentiment and some religious leaders use their power to instill fear and sometimes to encourage violence in their local jurisdictions towards sexual minorities (ILGA, 2010).
     While the social work profession has included sexual orientation as part of its anti-discrimination policies and does advocate for social change for not only the LGBT population, but for all people who are disenfranchised; current policy is missing several key components. A great way that the profession can frame policies are through the Yogyakarta Principles, in which a group of scholars took various UN human rights documents and show how LGBT human rights are not only included but are essential for our understanding of human rights. The principles were created because “…human rights violations targeted toward persons because of their actual or perceived sexual orientation or gender identity constitute a global and entrenched pattern of serious concern. They include extra-judicial killings, torture and ill-treatment, sexual assault and rape, invasions of privacy, arbitrary detention, denial of employment and education opportunities, and serious discrimination in relation to the enjoyment of other human rights. These violations are often compounded by experiences of other forms of violence, hatred, discrimination and exclusion, such as those based on race, age, religion, disability, or economic, social or other status (S. Correa, et. al.).” 
       Social work policy on the gay community should take into account the global impact of hate and discrimination. Homosexuality is one of the few characteristics that crosses all genders, faiths, nationalities, socio-economic statuses and cultures, yet it is one of the least understood. Indeed, even in countries where gay people have gained much ground as far as marriage rights and anti-discrimination laws, hate and prejudice still lives on in the minds of individuals. Therefore, the profession must include action in its policy and position statements on the international gay community. Social workers must be constantly vigilant to educate and empower the general public to speak out against homophobia and violence towards gay people. This is true even if homosexuality conflicts with the personal values of the social worker. Equally important, social workers must hold each other accountable to the promotion of gay rights because of the varying degrees of intolerance and educational attainment on gay issues within the profession. 
       Lastly, we must remember that gay rights and the promotion of equality are meaningless if we forget that we are not uplifting issues, we are uplifting people. The state-sanctioned killing of the Iranian teenagers, the murder of Matthew Shepard in the US, the conversion rape of black lesbians in South Africa and the militant slaughter of gays in Iraq all show the extreme violence that gay people face daily in the world. 
      Gay men and lesbians throughout history have faced oppression, discrimination, and eliminationism. The gay rights movement did not become a global phenomenon until the 1990's and great progress has been made. This progress however has been uneven and fraught with setbacks. In much of the global south, gay men and women face state sponsored harassment, imprisonment, fines and death and the world is largely ignorant to it. Social workers and the social work profession must be active in working toward eliminating homophobia, to pressure societies and governments to change their ideological stances toward gay people and commit them to inclusiveness and justice. If we, the most noble of professions, do not act swiftly and purposely, then we miss out on a major opportunity to advocate for one of the last accepted injustices left to face.