Showing posts with label Reproductive Health. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reproductive Health. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

United States of Fear

"And of course, the approach [to build] a multicultural [society] and to live side-by-side and to enjoy each other... has failed, utterly failed."
 -Angela Merkel, German Chancellor

"Rape and incest was used as a reason to oppose this. I would hope that when a woman goes into a physician, with a rape issue, that that physician will indeed ask her about perhaps her marriage, was this pregnancy caused by normal relations in a marriage, or was it truly caused by a rape." 
            -Chuck Winder, Idaho State Senate  Assistant Majority Leader

"That's what we're talking about whenever you're talking about gay rights. You're talking about giving somebody a gun to put at the head of anybody who disagrees with them, whether it's the Boy Scouts, whether it's a local dry-cleaning establishment or a giant corporation like Shell Oil." 
            -Robert Knight, Family Research Council

"[Gypsies] are nomads and nobody can do anything about them...they will bring their horses into the flats and there any attempt to civilize them ends...we should build special camps and keep them outside our cities."
           -Traian Bäsescu, Romanian President (Then Mayor of Bucharest)

   In 2008 when President Barack Obama was inaugurated, the world watched in hope that it would usher in a shining new era from what many saw as the draconian Bush years.  This reverberated so strongly that in 2009, President Obama was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize "for his extraordinary efforts to strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between peoples."  
      Much of the world saw him almost as a messiah figure whom to pin their belief that things were in fact, going to get better.  However like most idols, he could not live up to the herculean mission the world had placed on him.  In fact, his rise to the presidency coincided with the largest spike in the number of hate groups in memory and issues of racism, thought by much of white America to be a relic of the past, exploded to the surface.  This blog post is not intended to be a discussion about race politics in the US (hopefully that will be a discussion later on), but a commentary on the continental shifts in the US and around the globe that have occurred (and continue) since January of 2009.  
  Following on the heels of the collapse of Lehman Brothers and the housing crisis that we are all familiar with (some more intimately than others) began the worst global economic disaster since the market went belly up in 1929. Unlike previous regional problems like the collapse of several Latin American economys in the 1980's and the Asian financial crisis in the late 1990's; this was truly an economic pandemic.  Parts of the developing world recovered much quicker than the rest. The economic engine driving China, Brazil, and India barely slowed as they plowed through the recession.  In the developed world, especially the US and Europe, the recession may "officially" be over,but the  economic situation has continued to deteriorate.  Austerity measures in Greece have disenfranchised many jobless in the country and has yet to turn the Greek economy out of the red. In fact, talks about the Greek departure from the Eurozone is becoming more common in the European political arena.  Even Spain, the Eurozone's 4th biggest economy finally requested up to €100 billion to bail out of its banking sector.  The latest job figures in the United States show that only 69,000 jobs were created in May 2012 while unemployment rose to 8.2% nationally. 
  As the economic crisis deepens in many parts of the world, other social problems such as poverty, hunger, homelessness, debt, amongst others have been exacerbated.  Social discontent, while a permanent fixture on one level or another throughout history, has exploded throughout the world fueled by social media and easy access to information, with the "Arab Spring" as the most notable.   
  Underpinning this discontent is a layer of fear and anxiety about what the future may bring.  Interest in the "End Times" has reappeared in its current form through the ancient Mayan calendar and prophesies and television shows such as Ancient Aliens, the Universe, Ancient Discoveries, etc. have provided viewers with information about this event.  In fact, social media continues to have an impact through film (2012, Prometheus), television (Doomsday Preppers), books and articles (Post-American World, Third World America), and news outlets. 
  Unfortunately, when people become afraid, they'll turn to anyone who promises a solution.  Too often, the solutions include blaming "the other" for the losses that have been felt.  In France, members of the  Roma community were "repatriated" to Romania due to what officials called a "decent and humane" decision to move the individuals out of poor living conditions.  However, many in France accused then President Nicolas Sarkozy of pandering to the far right in his country as many believe that the nomadic Roma brought crime to the country with them when their countries of origin joined the Schengen Zone.  Also in France, as well as much of Europe, Islamophobia and antisemitism have launched new agenda's within the far right to curb immigration and as retribution against the actions of the State of Israel.  Violence against these groups are not uncommon. 
  In late May 2012, the FBI's hate biased crimes report showed that hate crimes have risen in the last year.  This has been true especially in the LGBT community where recent reports show that while probably under reported, this community is victimized 6 times the overall rate for the year of all groups.  Ministers in churches all over the country have advocated for the slaughter of gays as well and often ascribe the social ills of the country to the growing acceptance of the gay community.
  Within the last legislative session, women's reproductive rights have been increasingly restricted in many states across the US and throughout the world.  Initiatives to ban funding for organizations such as Planned Parenthood that provide abortion services have been attempted both on the federal and on state levels.  While the bulk of services that this organization provides are information, referral, family planning, rape crisis intervention, breast cancer screenings,etc., many on the right have used this state of fear to it's advantage to attack these services based on the small percentage of abortions provided each year. 
  As the ambitions of the far right continue to capitalize on the growing anxiety of the masses, social workers must continue to think critically about social problems and address them in a manner that is fact based and remain opposed to scapegoating of any population.  Even when we philosophically disagree with an individual or group we must remember that no one person nor a portion of a group can speak for the whole. 
  It will be interesting to see the dialogue as the US elections heat up toward November.  The first LDS front runner candidate against the first African American incumbent.  Two groups that have been historically marginalized in the US and who even have a divisive history amongst themselves.  As social workers we should remain on the forefront of issues facing the populations that we serve and respond promptly to any and all hate motivated speech targeted toward either candidate due to their minority status. 
 
Have you seen or read about anything related to this article? 
Please post your thoughts in the comment section. 
While all opinions are welcome. In order to create a safe space for dialogue, hate speech is not and will be removed.
   

Monday, August 29, 2011

Eugenics, Race, And A Woman's Right To Chose

"...the Negro lacks in his germ plasm excellence of some qualities which the white race possess, and which are essential for success in competition with the civilizations of the white races at the present day."
                                            - California, 1926

  Eugenics (termed by Francis Galton), or the means to "improve" the human race through infanticide, forced sterilization or genetic manipulation of those individuals deemed inferior (mental illness, low IQ, the poor, criminals, etc.) is rooted in the ancient philosophic works of Plato and Aristotle and has continued up to the present day.  The modern eugenics movement began in the late 19th century in the United States with the belief that criminality, imbecility and mental illness were hereditary and therefore should be controlled through forced sterilization or forced removal of "feeble-minded" children.   Some of the biggest proponents of the era weren't fringe characters or Nazi idealists but were arguably some of the most influential people of their time.  These included President Theodore Roosevelt, Planned Parenthood founder Margaret Sanger, Winston Churchill, and Economist John Maynard Keynes.  While the early years of the eugenics movement focused on poor white Americans, by the 1930's most of the forced sterilizations were on poor women of color.  Rooted in the belief that African Americans, Mexican Americans and Native Americans were genetically inferior to European Americans, social scientists of the day saw this reflected in data showing lower performance in education and in criminality.
  The Supreme Court showed the practice to be constitutionally viable in 1927 (Buck v. Bell) in regard to  the prevention of children born to people with disabilities.  The movement saw its greatest momentum between 1907 and 1968 when between 65,000 and 100,000 people were sterilized.  Clinics were placed in poor neighborhoods and eugenics propaganda was spread throughout America through county fairs where "fit family" contests were frequent.  This was not without notice to the rest of the world.  Nazi Germany used the eugenic framework from the US and other countries to justify the forced sterilizations of people with mental illness and developmental disabilities and the mass slaughter of Jews, Poles, Roma, Gays and others to root out less desirable races from their midst.
  The American social work profession, always being in transition, was unfortunately a major player in eugenics practices as they often were the gatekeepers of who received the procedure and who did not.  This also remained true in other countries where eugenic practices were the accepted "humanitarian" philosophy.
  In the wake of the Civil Rights Movement and the Feminist Movement of the 1960's, eugenic practices began to become highly unpopular as biologic science and social science began to show that race was not biologically determined but socially constructed.  Deficiencies in the classroom and overrepresentation in the prison system were shown to be the result of racist institutions and not on the genetic makeup of the individual.  Around this time social work also began to discredit eugenic philosophy as deeply flawed and shifted to a self-determination framework.  This fell in line with the belief that women have the right to informed reproductive health decisions and that the individual, not the state, has the right to choose regardless of race, gender or socio-economic status.
  Today eugenic practices seem to be nothing but a ghostly whisper from the past.  Indeed it has been relegated as junk science by most if not all mainstream professional organizations.  However, in much of the world, especially the Global South, women continue to lack access to reproductive freedom and up to date reproductive health information.  As a result of gender discrimination and poverty, women in the developing world are still at high risk of unwanted pregnancies, low education and literacy rates, HIV/AIDS, fistula, and maternal mortality.  In many parts of Asia, a war on girls is being waged in gender sex selection with a cultural preference to have boys.  This has lead to a major gender gap with a disproportionate number of boys over girls.  In China, with the one child policy, families without means are committing infanticide, aborting, or putting up for adoption girls in favor of their only child being a boy.
  Another modern concern arose with the advent of the Human Genome Project, an international collaboration to sequence the entire human genome.  This is believed to eventually lead to cures of genetic disorders, cancer, diabetes, mental illness, etc. and has been hailed as one of the greatest feats of modern science.   Indeed, one's perceived genetic make-up has lead to terrible atrocities in the past and with a future of designer babies, human-animal chimeras, and other eventualities, precautions must be made to prevent eugenic type philosophies from taking root again.
  One such precaution is for social workers to have a basic understanding of genetics if not have fluency in the field.  The National Association of Social Workers has developed practice standards for integrating genetic science into ones framework.  The inclusion of genetics into the education of social workers allows them to have the necessary tools to advocate with clients on all levels and to provide relevant information so clients may make informed decisions about their lives.