Showing posts with label access. Show all posts
Showing posts with label access. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Standing Guard Over Saraswati: The Freedom of Dissent

"In every age it has been the tyrant, the oppressor, and the exploiter who has wrapped himself in the cloak of patriotism, or religion, or both to deceive and overawe the People."
                                                                       -Eugene V. Debs, 1918
"My mother said I broke her heart...but it was my integrity that was important. Is that so selfish? It sells for so little, but it's all we have left in this place.  It is the very last inch of us...but within that inch we are free"
                                                                       -Alan Moore, V for Vendetta

  Today Egypt was drowned in violence.  It's army turned on it's civilians with arms and slaughtered hundreds of Morsi supporters simply because they wanted to be heard.  Alternately, when the Muslim Brotherhood was in power, they willfully ignored violence inflicted on the Coptic minority because they are different and are seen as a threat to power.
  In every age, in every part of the world, there are underground movements that seek the opportunity to climb out of the trenches and stand with their voices heard, without fear of ruin.  Enterprise and government (large and small) throughout history have made attempts to curb, stifle and snuff out those voices.  With righteous rage, ideas turn into movements and with collective action comes power.  Humans really aren't so different when faced with a wall of dissent. Whether in 17th century France, early 20th century Russia, or in 21st century America, people in power have supported corrupt government policies that continue to alienate and intimidate minority opinion and minority rights.  Governments, however democratically elected, do not act alone but with the silent approval of the masses who keep their hands on the wheel, eyes forward.
  Not unlike governments, corporations have the capacity and will to stifle any opinion or threat to their bottom line.  During the height of European expansion, large businesses expanded to the New and parts of the Old World to obtain goods not previously available to the masses of the Continent.  Whether in the Americas, India, the South Pacific or Africa, these new industries toppled local governments and often installed puppet institutions to continue to feed the expanding empires. More recently in parts of the developing world; gas, coffee, water and the like drive conglomerates to continue to suppress dissent in countries who's annual GDP are fractions of their annual profits.  Not unlike the factory conditions during the early 20th century, farm and factory workers are forced to slave from sun up to sun down for less than $1 per day so that we in the developed world can spend less on the items we desire.  In Bangladesh for example, textile exports continue to surge despite over 1,000 deaths in a factory collapse in April.  Calls for reform have trumpeted from all corners of the globe and yet tangible change in the country to protect it's workers have stalled as some corporations like Walmart and Gap refuse to allow collective bargaining agreements with their workers thus disallowing real progress.
  In the US and in many democratic nations, we hold virtuous principles in our hearts and lack the integrity to follow through with them because they interfere with our ends.  Dissent in any form outside of violence must be tolerated and at best celebrated because it demonstrates a truly free society.
  As a Social Worker, wherever you are in the world, whatever you do to change your part of the world. We are the voice for the voiceless and we are the embodiment of dissent.  We are the call to justice and the rallying cry of freedom.  Where we see opinions and beliefs stifled, even if we disagree with them, we must stand with their right to say it.  That is how we maintain our integrity within our profession.  

Saturday, June 11, 2011

Access to social service – or lack there of ...The case of Hartford, Connecticut


I am not the betting type, but I would be willing to put stakes that the average person living in an urban area does not know what social services are in a one mile radius, what they are fully entitled to (based on residence, income, familial status...), or how to access their entitlements. However, statistics show that the majority populace of urban cities will take advantage of some social service at least once in their residence. Thus there is a dysfunctional relationship between knowledge and access.

Taking this dichotomy one step further, I did some research. The last time the social services in Hartford Connecticut were formally mapped out was in an article by the Kennedy School about the 1994 moratorium on social services titled Zoning Restrictions on Social Services for the Poor: The Case of Hartford, Connecticut.

Abstract: “This case about the regulation of nonprofit social service organizations focuses on the unusual decision of the Hartford (Connecticut) City Council: to impose a moratorium on the establishment of new social service nonprofit organizations-such as homeless shelters and drug treatment centers-in the center city, where such uses had greatly proliferated in the 1980s and 1990s. The case allows for discussion of urban policy-is it better to serve a city's poor population or take steps meant to limit service "magnets" which might attract the poor? Is it government's job to serve citizens or attempt to upgrade neighborhoods? The case also allows for a broader, nonprofit policy discussion of the limits and dimensions of public regulation of non-governmental organizations, a discussion complicated by the public funds which support organizations such as those in Hartford.”

This case is extremely important to the social work field for several reasons, humor me - I am going to list a few:

1. It was impacted by and continues to impact all 5 branches of social work (casework, group work, admin, community organization, and policy practice) hence why it is taught in macro foundation

2. Hartford is the scapegoat city for all things that go wrong, this is just one of those examples.

3. The very question on knowledge and access are addressed in this case

4. The fundamental question is still yet to be answered: how much positive change has occurred since the closure of the case?

Skipping straight to number 4... I took some time (too much perhaps) to collect directories and data to produce a new map of the social services located IN and AROUND Hartford Connecticut. Many of the fundamental problems from the 90's still exist today, so to answer the question, not enough has changed in my opinion. Many of the social services are either located in the downtown business districts (i.e. not where people live) or further away on the outskirts of the city. Generally not in the same neighborhood where the target population for the social service lives and (most importantly) not on a bus route.

A note on public transportation in Hartford. First of all, the website is only minimally "user friendly". More importantly, good luck getting where you need to go in a full day if you rely on the buses. See, the bus system looks like a bike tire with the center of Hartford in the middle and all of the spokes are different bus routes. However, there is no tire around the outside, more over, one route does not connect to another. So, if you live out of the center of the city, you'll have to take a bus in. Chances are if you have a doctors appointment, have to pick the kids up from school, drop off some dry cleaning, and then make your way home, you're going to be taking quite a few buses. The slogan for CT Transit is "connecting communitites" yet the routes do not connect...irony.

Back to the map. It was created with the intention of being spread to both the academic community and to the local level where individuals and social services could benefit. As you zoom in on the map itself, the location of the organization, name, and type of service provided show up in a box along with publicly accessible contact information. The idea is that with access to knowledge comes greater understanding. And with greater understanding we as social workers, and we as people are able to better help one another. So, as stated back in the first paragraph, most people in an urban city will utilize a social service during their residence. However, many people do not know the full realm of what they are entitled to. Utilizing this map is one step towards helping people see what social services are accessible around them as well as understanding what social services are most frequently (or less for that matter) accessed and why.