Showing posts with label Self-Determination. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Self-Determination. Show all posts

Thursday, October 13, 2011

Don't Ask, Don't Tell


As a social worker, a peace activist, and someone who has long worked for equality for LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender) people, the repeal of the military’s Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell policy was certainly something to be happy about.  I am certainly happy that those in my community will no longer be discharged simply for being who they are.  However, there are some larger issues with the U.S. military which I believe prohibit me from supporting the idea that this institution is capable of contributing to human well-being.  I am writing this so that I might draw attention to what I see as the professional ethical concerns between the social work profession and the U.S. military, and express why my new ability to be openly gay and die for capitalism does not impress me.  Before I get started, though, I would like to make a personal statement. 
Many military families hear my views on this subject and call me ungrateful for their sacrifices, but I write this in solidarity because I also come from a military family.  My father entered therapy after our family reached a crisis point, thirty-five years after front line combat in Vietnam.  Growing up, we always thought that the manifestation of his Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) was the result of the awful violence he must have seen in combat.  Intensive individual and group therapy with other veteran victims of PTSD helped him to articulate that the PTSD was actually from the U.S. military training, not from the combat.  If you spoke to his group members, you’d hear similar stories from all of them. 
The training is designed to teach soldiers to overcome resistance to killing.  This ability to overcome resistance to killing might explain why 18 veterans a day are committing suicide, and 76% are returning home with alcohol and drug addiction problems, according to the National Coalition for Homeless Veterans.  As a society, we’re also having a very challenging time keeping LGBT youth from committing suicide because of bullying.  The U.S. military is doing to soldiers what school administration’s failures to adequately address bullying are doing to LGBT youth.  Systematic institutional violence erodes the human spirit to such an extent that the ability to continue living becomes inhibited.  This leads me to addressing what I see as the prominent concerns in relation to these subjects from the NASW (National Association of Social Workers) Code of Ethics:  The statement on Peace and Social Justice and the client’s right to self determination. 
In the NASW Code of Ethics, the statement on Peace and Social Justice says that “We must reduce the use of violence as a solution to domestic as well as foreign problems. “  I would criticize that by taking it a step further and say that not only should we work to reduce violence; we should abolish institutional violence and the institutions that thrive because of it.  To only reduce is to say that some violence is acceptable. 
Additionally, in section 6.01 the NASW Code of Ethics states that “Social workers should promote the general welfare of society, from local to global levels, and the development of people, their communities, and their environments. Social workers should advocate for living conditions conducive to the fulfillment of basic human needs and should promote social, economic, political, and cultural values and institutions that are compatible with the realization of social justice.”  If we are going to adhere to this ethical responsibility, how can we agree that only a reduction in violence is satisfactory?  How can we support institutions which depend on violence for economic prosperity?  As social workers we may find ourselves in situations with our clients where they are considering joining, supporting or otherwise condoning the U.S. military.  This leads me to the ethical concern of the client’s right to self determination.
The statement on self-determination says the following:  “Social workers may limit clients' right to self-determination when, in the social workers' professional judgment, clients' actions or potential actions pose a serious, foreseeable, and imminent risk to themselves or others.”  If it wasn’t the U.S. military, and a client was considering condoning any other institution which resulted in 18 daily suicides and a 76% drug and alcohol addiction rate, I believe that this exemption to self-determination would apply without a doubt.  Certainly general self-determination guidelines would not apply in the case of a suicidal LGBT youth client.  Shouldn’t the same apply to condoning institutions where suicide and other high-risk behaviors are a more than likely outcome?  This leads me to believing that supporting anything less than full and total disarmament means I am failing in this ethical responsibility.  In the spirit of disarmament, peace, and social justice, I will close with the following thoughts.
There are some reasons that I can be excited about and thankful for the repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell.  The reasons are that we now have the opportunity to organize more inclusive peace activism.  The voices of LGBT people in peace activism and war resistance are more valuable now than they have ever been.  Repealing Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell might be empowering for LGBT people in the military (and I am happy for them because of that), but post-repeal inclusive peace activism can be empowering for LGBT people everywhere.  We can always hope that repealing discrimination within the military might be a step towards repealing the military altogether.    

Monday, August 29, 2011

Eugenics, Race, And A Woman's Right To Chose

"...the Negro lacks in his germ plasm excellence of some qualities which the white race possess, and which are essential for success in competition with the civilizations of the white races at the present day."
                                            - California, 1926

  Eugenics (termed by Francis Galton), or the means to "improve" the human race through infanticide, forced sterilization or genetic manipulation of those individuals deemed inferior (mental illness, low IQ, the poor, criminals, etc.) is rooted in the ancient philosophic works of Plato and Aristotle and has continued up to the present day.  The modern eugenics movement began in the late 19th century in the United States with the belief that criminality, imbecility and mental illness were hereditary and therefore should be controlled through forced sterilization or forced removal of "feeble-minded" children.   Some of the biggest proponents of the era weren't fringe characters or Nazi idealists but were arguably some of the most influential people of their time.  These included President Theodore Roosevelt, Planned Parenthood founder Margaret Sanger, Winston Churchill, and Economist John Maynard Keynes.  While the early years of the eugenics movement focused on poor white Americans, by the 1930's most of the forced sterilizations were on poor women of color.  Rooted in the belief that African Americans, Mexican Americans and Native Americans were genetically inferior to European Americans, social scientists of the day saw this reflected in data showing lower performance in education and in criminality.
  The Supreme Court showed the practice to be constitutionally viable in 1927 (Buck v. Bell) in regard to  the prevention of children born to people with disabilities.  The movement saw its greatest momentum between 1907 and 1968 when between 65,000 and 100,000 people were sterilized.  Clinics were placed in poor neighborhoods and eugenics propaganda was spread throughout America through county fairs where "fit family" contests were frequent.  This was not without notice to the rest of the world.  Nazi Germany used the eugenic framework from the US and other countries to justify the forced sterilizations of people with mental illness and developmental disabilities and the mass slaughter of Jews, Poles, Roma, Gays and others to root out less desirable races from their midst.
  The American social work profession, always being in transition, was unfortunately a major player in eugenics practices as they often were the gatekeepers of who received the procedure and who did not.  This also remained true in other countries where eugenic practices were the accepted "humanitarian" philosophy.
  In the wake of the Civil Rights Movement and the Feminist Movement of the 1960's, eugenic practices began to become highly unpopular as biologic science and social science began to show that race was not biologically determined but socially constructed.  Deficiencies in the classroom and overrepresentation in the prison system were shown to be the result of racist institutions and not on the genetic makeup of the individual.  Around this time social work also began to discredit eugenic philosophy as deeply flawed and shifted to a self-determination framework.  This fell in line with the belief that women have the right to informed reproductive health decisions and that the individual, not the state, has the right to choose regardless of race, gender or socio-economic status.
  Today eugenic practices seem to be nothing but a ghostly whisper from the past.  Indeed it has been relegated as junk science by most if not all mainstream professional organizations.  However, in much of the world, especially the Global South, women continue to lack access to reproductive freedom and up to date reproductive health information.  As a result of gender discrimination and poverty, women in the developing world are still at high risk of unwanted pregnancies, low education and literacy rates, HIV/AIDS, fistula, and maternal mortality.  In many parts of Asia, a war on girls is being waged in gender sex selection with a cultural preference to have boys.  This has lead to a major gender gap with a disproportionate number of boys over girls.  In China, with the one child policy, families without means are committing infanticide, aborting, or putting up for adoption girls in favor of their only child being a boy.
  Another modern concern arose with the advent of the Human Genome Project, an international collaboration to sequence the entire human genome.  This is believed to eventually lead to cures of genetic disorders, cancer, diabetes, mental illness, etc. and has been hailed as one of the greatest feats of modern science.   Indeed, one's perceived genetic make-up has lead to terrible atrocities in the past and with a future of designer babies, human-animal chimeras, and other eventualities, precautions must be made to prevent eugenic type philosophies from taking root again.
  One such precaution is for social workers to have a basic understanding of genetics if not have fluency in the field.  The National Association of Social Workers has developed practice standards for integrating genetic science into ones framework.  The inclusion of genetics into the education of social workers allows them to have the necessary tools to advocate with clients on all levels and to provide relevant information so clients may make informed decisions about their lives.